Jump to content

Featured Replies

  • Replies 106
  • Views 13.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Is it too early to be whining about our DC who hasn't even had a chance to do ANYTHING yet with this new group of players?

  • The fans may have bigger balls, but the players don't (anymore)  The CFL ball is the same dimensions now as the NFL one.  The older J5V was larger, but that goes back a few years.   Some of the majo

  • There is about a 20 minute interview up with bob irving on cjob website where he talks about the mini camp.   Actually it was on the upperdeck sports show at about 607 to 635 ish.   Some of the th

comment_46937

IMO Coach Mike made a BIG mistake by declaring Drew the Starter.  I really want to like O'shea but really why did he say that?  That, IMO is worse than when Kelly declared Lefors the starter.  At least Lefors started a preseason game before Kelly made his declaration...

Willy has more talent in his little finger than LeFors ever had. We'll be just fine with Drew Willy. Relax.

comment_46940

IMO Coach Mike made a BIG mistake by declaring Drew the Starter. I really want to like O'shea but really why did he say that? That, IMO is worse than when Kelly declared Lefors the starter. At least Lefors started a preseason game before Kelly made his declaration...

Willy has more talent in his little finger than LeFors ever had. We'll be just fine with Drew Willy. Relax.

Lol not true at all! But hey hopefully his fate ends up better then Lefors

comment_46983

There's something to be said for instilling confidence in a guy by letting him know what his job will be in June, so he can just go ahead and prepare for that. Also something to be said for not having any swirling controversy going into the season. Everyone knows where they stand...now go do your job.

comment_46988

There's something to be said for instilling confidence in a guy by letting him know what his job will be in June, so he can just go ahead and prepare for that. Also something to be said for not having any swirling controversy going into the season. Everyone knows where they stand...now go do your job.

It was annoying as hell having Burke flip flop every week on who the starter will be.

It only makes sense that we have a clear direction. Willy will be fine and I'm sure it can't be any worse then Goltz and his 110 yards per game...

comment_46989

 

 

IMO Coach Mike made a BIG mistake by declaring Drew the Starter. I really want to like O'shea but really why did he say that? That, IMO is worse than when Kelly declared Lefors the starter. At least Lefors started a preseason game before Kelly made his declaration...

Willy has more talent in his little finger than LeFors ever had. We'll be just fine with Drew Willy. Relax.

Lol not true at all! But hey hopefully his fate ends up better then Lefors

 

I don't know fellas. How bout that Marve kid? I'm a big fan of competing for the starting spot. Just saying. 

comment_46990

 

There's something to be said for instilling confidence in a guy by letting him know what his job will be in June, so he can just go ahead and prepare for that. Also something to be said for not having any swirling controversy going into the season. Everyone knows where they stand...now go do your job.

It was annoying as hell having Burke flip flop every week on who the starter will be.

It only makes sense that we have a clear direction. Willy will be fine and I'm sure it can't be any worse then Goltz and his 110 yards per game...

 

But shouldn't the 'best' guy start? I'm just asking, what IF you've got somebody that is just better? 

  • Author
comment_46991

 

 

There's something to be said for instilling confidence in a guy by letting him know what his job will be in June, so he can just go ahead and prepare for that. Also something to be said for not having any swirling controversy going into the season. Everyone knows where they stand...now go do your job.

It was annoying as hell having Burke flip flop every week on who the starter will be.

It only makes sense that we have a clear direction. Willy will be fine and I'm sure it can't be any worse then Goltz and his 110 yards per game...

 

But shouldn't the 'best' guy start? I'm just asking, what IF you've got somebody that is just better? 

 

 

I'll start off by saying that it's always going to be a little bit difficult to understand when you're so deeply invested in one of the horses in the race, but in pro football ... the #4 guy doesn't become the #1 guy overnight. It just doesn't happen.

 

Marve could go into camp, be lights out and look like the consensus best QB out of the four. And he still wouldn't start week one.

comment_46992

 

 

There's something to be said for instilling confidence in a guy by letting him know what his job will be in June, so he can just go ahead and prepare for that. Also something to be said for not having any swirling controversy going into the season. Everyone knows where they stand...now go do your job.

It was annoying as hell having Burke flip flop every week on who the starter will be.

It only makes sense that we have a clear direction. Willy will be fine and I'm sure it can't be any worse then Goltz and his 110 yards per game...

 

But shouldn't the 'best' guy start? I'm just asking, what IF you've got somebody that is just better? 

 

 

After we go through camp and Exhibition, I'm sure the "best" guy will start week one, whomever that will be. O'Shea will not put the team in a poor position simply because they anointed Willy the starter in February.

comment_46993

 

 

 

There's something to be said for instilling confidence in a guy by letting him know what his job will be in June, so he can just go ahead and prepare for that. Also something to be said for not having any swirling controversy going into the season. Everyone knows where they stand...now go do your job.

It was annoying as hell having Burke flip flop every week on who the starter will be.

It only makes sense that we have a clear direction. Willy will be fine and I'm sure it can't be any worse then Goltz and his 110 yards per game...

 

But shouldn't the 'best' guy start? I'm just asking, what IF you've got somebody that is just better? 

 

 

After we go through camp and Exhibition, I'm sure the "best" guy will start week one, whomever that will be. O'Shea will not put the team in a poor position simply because they anointed Willy the starter in February.

 

Yes he will.  They're not paying Willy around 250K to sit on the bench.

comment_46995

Not having the sort of experience with the Canadian game that Willy has puts Marvelous Marve at a serious disadvantage, at least as far as starting is concerned. Max Hall is going into his second season and looked like he was picking up the game more and more every time he stepped on the field. Marve is in tough to even be #2 out of camp. It doesn't mean for a second he isn't a good/talented QB, it just means he's going to have to work his way up the ranks like virtually everyone else.

comment_46997

 

 

 

There's something to be said for instilling confidence in a guy by letting him know what his job will be in June, so he can just go ahead and prepare for that. Also something to be said for not having any swirling controversy going into the season. Everyone knows where they stand...now go do your job.

It was annoying as hell having Burke flip flop every week on who the starter will be.

It only makes sense that we have a clear direction. Willy will be fine and I'm sure it can't be any worse then Goltz and his 110 yards per game...

 

But shouldn't the 'best' guy start? I'm just asking, what IF you've got somebody that is just better? 

 

 

I'll start off by saying that it's always going to be a little bit difficult to understand when you're so deeply invested in one of the horses in the race, but in pro football ... the #4 guy doesn't become the #1 guy overnight. It just doesn't happen.

 

Marve could go into camp, be lights out and look like the consensus best QB out of the four. And he still wouldn't start week one.

 

Understood, but, if you've got a guy that can improve, at what point do you give him a shot. Aye...I've never seen this starter play and yes I'm biased......just wondering, that's all. 

  • Author
comment_47000

 

 

 

 

There's something to be said for instilling confidence in a guy by letting him know what his job will be in June, so he can just go ahead and prepare for that. Also something to be said for not having any swirling controversy going into the season. Everyone knows where they stand...now go do your job.

It was annoying as hell having Burke flip flop every week on who the starter will be.

It only makes sense that we have a clear direction. Willy will be fine and I'm sure it can't be any worse then Goltz and his 110 yards per game...

 

But shouldn't the 'best' guy start? I'm just asking, what IF you've got somebody that is just better? 

 

 

I'll start off by saying that it's always going to be a little bit difficult to understand when you're so deeply invested in one of the horses in the race, but in pro football ... the #4 guy doesn't become the #1 guy overnight. It just doesn't happen.

 

Marve could go into camp, be lights out and look like the consensus best QB out of the four. And he still wouldn't start week one.

 

Understood, but, if you've got a guy that can improve, at what point do you give him a shot. Aye...I've never seen this starter play and yes I'm biased......just wondering, that's all. 

 

 

You give him a shot when he's ready. And the reality is that unless he's going to come in and be a "once in a generation" kind of talent, he won't be ready for at least a year. Probably two or three.

comment_47004

We all get excited when we hear good things about a QB we have in our camp.

A QB who can throw a bus, instead of being thrown under one.

It's better than what we usually hear…"his arm is suspect."

 

R. Marve's 1st goal will be to supplant B. Brohm on the depth chart, then M. Hall.

He's got a ways to go.

Strong-arming your way into position only works in the arm-wrestling, the mafia or politics.  -_-

 

 

comment_47006

Robert Marve is not starting week one (or anytime soon). Period. You're not going to stroll out a QB who has never suited up in a CFL game before especially when you're trying to generate as much positive press as possible coming off of a 3-15 season.

I here you. I would use the same argument however....coming off of a 3-15 season, let's shake it up a bit. Again, I haven't seen the other's so I guess we just wait and see. Hope the O line is strong enough to protect whoever is back there. 

comment_47011

2 days of mini camp or so where none of us where, based on reports from guys like penton and irving and some think marve should be starting?

 

Things never change around these parts, not sure why we would want to throw a rookie under the bus already, and marve is a rookie, Willy isnt.

 

If people want marve to actually be a good one, you dont throw him under center week 1 because by week 3 he will be gone.

 

Honestly, im not sure whats more insane, wanting to start marve based on 2 days of mini camp or wanting to start hutchinson based on 3 games played with the JETS.

 

Right now, marve is the #4 qb on the depth chart, he's the developmental (4 man/PR) qb. You dont throw him in there week 1. You give him time to learn the game. Oh and btw, just cuz he had 2 solid days at a mini camp, doesnt mean anything. He's still #4 and the developmental qb.

Create an account or sign in to comment