December 18, 20195 yr comment_454561 1 hour ago, Jacquie said: Not necessarily. We've seen in the past how some top NFL players were absolute duds in the CFL. You're talking about players who were top guys at one point in their careers. By the time they try the CFL most are just trying to find their game again.
December 18, 20195 yr comment_454572 2 hours ago, Jacquie said: Not necessarily. We've seen in the past how some top NFL players were absolute duds in the CFL. That's true to an extent... but we've never really seen a true NFL superstar, in their prime, compete in the CFL... Most guys who have come to the CFL and failed are not, and probably never were, at the level of the list that I quoted...
December 18, 20195 yr comment_454573 4 minutes ago, bearpants said: That's true to an extent... but we've never really seen a true NFL superstar, in their prime, compete in the CFL... Most guys who have come to the CFL and failed are not, and probably never were, at the level of the list that I quoted... Vince Ferragamo says hello
December 18, 20195 yr comment_454580 18 minutes ago, Booch said: Vince Ferragamo says hello so does Ricky Williams.....although not a "dud" in the CFL, he was pretty average. 526 rushing yards in 11 games, 2 TD's. Certainly there were many NFL fans who thought he would dominate here, but he didn't.
December 18, 20195 yr comment_454581 Doug Flutie, warren moon, Jeff garcia... these were all ‘NFL’ talents who were in the cfl in their prime
December 18, 20195 yr comment_454593 40 minutes ago, Floyd said: Doug Flutie, warren moon, Jeff garcia... these were all ‘NFL’ talents who were in the cfl in their prime True... and these players were all CFL superstars...
December 18, 20195 yr comment_454599 10 minutes ago, bearpants said: True... and these players were all CFL superstars... And Whiteshoes Johnson, although not such a CFL superstar. Edited December 18, 20195 yr by Tracker
December 18, 20195 yr comment_454600 10 minutes ago, bearpants said: True... and these players were all CFL superstars... That’d be true, but also, they were football superstars. They shone in both leagues.
December 18, 20195 yr comment_454604 On 2019-12-14 at 7:25 AM, Geebrr said: Calgary was spoiled Still are.
December 18, 20195 yr comment_454606 18 hours ago, wbbfan said: Tyreek hill on the cfl field would unstoppable. Bo jackson in tecmo bowl unstoppable. Brandon Banks, but bigger, faster, and better.
December 18, 20195 yr comment_454618 2 hours ago, Jaxon said: so does Ricky Williams.....although not a "dud" in the CFL, he was pretty average. 526 rushing yards in 11 games, 2 TD's. Certainly there were many NFL fans who thought he would dominate here, but he didn't. Yup... Guy went on from having a pretty mediocre season in the CFL to be a reasonably good rusher in the NFL for another 5 years (including a 1000 yard rushing season in 2008). Probably a pretty good example of a Tier 2 (not absolutely elite, but highly regarded) NFL athlete who was only good when he came to the CFL (if he'd been able to play for the entire year he would have been in the mix for best RB in the league... but definitely not a hands down selection).
December 18, 20195 yr comment_454623 1 hour ago, sweep the leg said: Brandon Banks, but bigger, faster, and better. Yep. Can you imagine what he would do in brandon banks role in hamilton? insanity. 37 minutes ago, BomberfanMKS said: Yup... Guy went on from having a pretty mediocre season in the CFL to be a reasonably good rusher in the NFL for another 5 years (including a 1000 yard rushing season in 2008). Probably a pretty good example of a Tier 2 (not absolutely elite, but highly regarded) NFL athlete who was only good when he came to the CFL (if he'd been able to play for the entire year he would have been in the mix for best RB in the league... but definitely not a hands down selection). Ricky williams was more then reasonably good when he returned to the nfl. He had the second best year of his career. 1,121 rushing yards, 4.7 YPC 11 tds with 264 receiving yards and 2 more tds. 1,385 yards from the line and 13 tds isnt second tier, or only good. He would not have been in the discussion for best back that year. He played just under 2/3s of the season, if you doubled his totals he would end up 600 rushing yards and 8 tds behind charles roberts (hed also be 150 yards receiving behind blink for about 750 total yards behind) We see countless high tier prospects sizzle out in camp despite nfl success and great ncaa pedigree because they cant adapt their skill set to the cfl game. Plenty of stars would not make it up here because they have been doing the same stuff from HS to ncaa, to the NFL and wouldnt be able to adapt. A bunch of physical Dbs, Qbs who run heavy sets and are ok to read 3 pass options, we havent seen a TE succeed in the cfl in ages (though I think it could make a come back) and positions that dont over lap here, a chunk of backs wouldnt make it for not being able to make it out of the heavy set us schemes or with the huge volume. Just like any thing else, a player can be a star with another team in the league but not make it after a trade or FA contract. Or guys who get cut up here only to get another nfl contract and stick. Elite play can be very fleeting. How many stars in the nfl, cfl and ncaa look bad when they suddenly go from playing mostly in warm weather / domes to playing in freezing temperatures and snow?
December 23, 20195 yr comment_455117 On 2019-12-18 at 11:42 AM, bearpants said: True... and these players were all CFL superstars... Joe Theisman, Jake Scott, Vic Washington, Margene Adkins, Joe Kapp & Tom Cousineau.
December 24, 20195 yr comment_455277 So many names so little action ( so far) . How long before someone floats a "collusion" theory ?
December 24, 20195 yr comment_455284 49 minutes ago, Zontar said: So many names so little action ( so far) . How long before someone floats a "collusion" theory ? Merry Christmas, Zontar. Glad you're back.
December 24, 20195 yr comment_455286 6 minutes ago, SpeedFlex27 said: Merry Christmas, Zontar. Glad you're back. Happy Christmas to you. Not a whole lot to talk about from my corner of the garden....yet.
January 2, 20205 yr comment_455744 On 2019-12-24 at 6:37 PM, Zontar said: Happy Christmas to you. Not a whole lot to talk about from my corner of the garden....yet. Yeah, good to see you. Looking forward to 2020.
August 24, 20231 yr comment_655384 On 2019-12-03 at 8:46 AM, Geebrr said: I have a feeling Jake Thomas will hang up the cleats for good this year. I always navigate threads by clicking the "Next unread topic" button. So I always get a daily dose of #oldtakesexposed that I ignore because hindsight is 20/20. But this one was funny. 4 years later!
August 24, 20231 yr comment_655481 5 hours ago, Jesse said: I always navigate threads by clicking the "Next unread topic" button. So I always get a daily dose of #oldtakesexposed that I ignore because hindsight is 20/20. But this one was funny. 4 years later! I’m pretty confident he will retire with in the next 4 years though… …. .. maybe.
August 24, 20231 yr comment_655485 6 minutes ago, wbbfan said: I’m pretty confident he will retire with in the next 4 years though… …. .. maybe. Ok but 2019 was not 4 years ago.. 2019 was like two months ago…holy crap does time fly!
August 24, 20231 yr comment_655495 45 minutes ago, Arnold_Palmer said: Ok but 2019 was not 4 years ago.. 2019 was like two months ago…holy crap does time fly! the pandemic:
_4ce1be.png)
_4ccb55.png)
_b2ed7a.png)
