Jump to content

Featured Replies

comment_53474

Who has our best tackler arguably been the last few seasons, i'd argue that it was the smallest guy on the field, alex suber. So yeah size really doesn't matter as much as some are making it out to be. And prior to him, could argue it was that gigantic 5'9 maybe monster in jonathan hefney. Size doesn't mean much really.

who do you think is harder to block? Zach Anderson or Alex Suber? Don't tell me size doesn't matter... especially in the run game

That depends. It'd be much easier to catch Anderson. You need to catch up to the guy before even attempting to tackle.

  • Replies 87
  • Views 8.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Anderson needs to be on the field as much as possible and they better not try and tell me he doesn't fit Etcheverry's idea of a DT because he's historically exactly what Etch has looked for.   That

  • gbill2004
    gbill2004

    Tackling is all about technique.

  • Zach Anderson 3rd on the chart... If Etch ends up cutting him I'm breaking out the pitch fork and torches

comment_53501

Who has our best tackler arguably been the last few seasons, i'd argue that it was the smallest guy on the field, alex suber. So yeah size really doesn't matter as much as some are making it out to be. And prior to him, could argue it was that gigantic 5'9 maybe monster in jonathan hefney. Size doesn't mean much really.

Except that when Suber tackles a guy it's in the open field, how good a tackler would he be if he had to shed blocks from very large angry men to make those tackles?

comment_53509

 

Who has our best tackler arguably been the last few seasons, i'd argue that it was the smallest guy on the field, alex suber. So yeah size really doesn't matter as much as some are making it out to be. And prior to him, could argue it was that gigantic 5'9 maybe monster in jonathan hefney. Size doesn't mean much really.

Except that when Suber tackles a guy it's in the open field, how good a tackler would he be if he had to shed blocks from very large angry men to make those tackles?

 

 

You could easily argue that open field tackling is harder... but I'm not going to....

 

I'll take more stock in the depth chart once the roster is announced...

comment_53514

 

 

Who has our best tackler arguably been the last few seasons, i'd argue that it was the smallest guy on the field, alex suber. So yeah size really doesn't matter as much as some are making it out to be. And prior to him, could argue it was that gigantic 5'9 maybe monster in jonathan hefney. Size doesn't mean much really.

Except that when Suber tackles a guy it's in the open field, how good a tackler would he be if he had to shed blocks from very large angry men to make those tackles?

 

 

You could easily argue that open field tackling is harder... but I'm not going to....

 

I'll take more stock in the depth chart once the roster is announced...

 

harder in a different way but easier in other ways too. 

comment_53515

 

 

Who has our best tackler arguably been the last few seasons, i'd argue that it was the smallest guy on the field, alex suber. So yeah size really doesn't matter as much as some are making it out to be. And prior to him, could argue it was that gigantic 5'9 maybe monster in jonathan hefney. Size doesn't mean much really.

Except that when Suber tackles a guy it's in the open field, how good a tackler would he be if he had to shed blocks from very large angry men to make those tackles?

 

 

You could easily argue that open field tackling is harder... but I'm not going to....

 

I'll take more stock in the depth chart once the roster is announced...

 

 

You can't really compare the two

 

Shedding blocks to make a gap tackle vs. Open field tackle

 

Sure open field tackling probably takes more technical skill... shedding blocks requires size and strength (when you are trying to shed a 300lb Olineman)

 

Suber is a great open field tackler... I wouldn't ask him to bull rush an OL

comment_53516

 

 

 

Who has our best tackler arguably been the last few seasons, i'd argue that it was the smallest guy on the field, alex suber. So yeah size really doesn't matter as much as some are making it out to be. And prior to him, could argue it was that gigantic 5'9 maybe monster in jonathan hefney. Size doesn't mean much really.

Except that when Suber tackles a guy it's in the open field, how good a tackler would he be if he had to shed blocks from very large angry men to make those tackles?

 

 

You could easily argue that open field tackling is harder... but I'm not going to....

 

I'll take more stock in the depth chart once the roster is announced...

 

 

You can't really compare the two

 

Shedding blocks to make a gap tackle vs. Open field tackle

 

Sure open field tackling probably takes more technical skill... shedding blocks requires size and strength (when you are trying to shed a 300lb Olineman)

 

Suber is a great open field tackler... I wouldn't ask him to bull rush an OL

 

 

I'm not trying to start an argument here, just food for thought.... if you compare apples-to-apples when it comes to tackling would it be easier for Suber bullrush a 5'10 190lb O-linemen or Anderson to tackle a 6'2 260lb runner in the open field? Probably the former... I personally think sure open field tacklers are far more rare in the CFL

comment_53518

 

 

 

 

Who has our best tackler arguably been the last few seasons, i'd argue that it was the smallest guy on the field, alex suber. So yeah size really doesn't matter as much as some are making it out to be. And prior to him, could argue it was that gigantic 5'9 maybe monster in jonathan hefney. Size doesn't mean much really.

Except that when Suber tackles a guy it's in the open field, how good a tackler would he be if he had to shed blocks from very large angry men to make those tackles?

 

 

You could easily argue that open field tackling is harder... but I'm not going to....

 

I'll take more stock in the depth chart once the roster is announced...

 

 

You can't really compare the two

 

Shedding blocks to make a gap tackle vs. Open field tackle

 

Sure open field tackling probably takes more technical skill... shedding blocks requires size and strength (when you are trying to shed a 300lb Olineman)

 

Suber is a great open field tackler... I wouldn't ask him to bull rush an OL

 

 

I'm not trying to start an argument here, just food for thought.... if you compare apples-to-apples when it comes to tackling would it be easier for Suber bullrush a 5'10 190lb O-linemen or Anderson to tackle a 6'2 260lb runner in the open field? Probably the former... I personally think sure open field tacklers are far more rare in the CFL

 

 

I'd say both would do a poor job and probably miss more often than not (Suber wouldn't close the gap / Anderson would miss the open field tackle)

 

Thats why Anderson is the guy we get to close the gap and Suber is the guy we have making open field tackles...

 

But yeh sure... sometimes suber could get enough of his body in the way to be able to trip up an RB in the gap... he probably wouldn't last many games in that role though

comment_53635

While I hate the idea of Zach Anderson getting bumped out of a starting role, I don't mind Ryan Lucas... he was actually getting lots of reps and looking quite good last year until Jon Gott ended his season with a pretty questionable block.  I do believe that Lucas is our best option as a second Canadian starter on defence.... better than using two NI's in the secondary or trying to wedge Graig Newman into a starting MLB role, at least.

comment_53664

Mike O'shea today on his PC, up on the official site, said to not look to far into depth charts at this place and time, they are just really trying to get guys reps.

 

So with t hat being said, don't probably need to worry about guys like anderson washington wild. They will more than likely be on the team. 

comment_53671

Mike O'shea today on his PC, up on the official site, said to not look to far into depth charts at this place and time, they are just really trying to get guys reps.

 

So with t hat being said, don't probably need to worry about guys like anderson washington wild. They will more than likely be on the team. 

 

Yeah I don't doubt it.  O'Shea was pretty complimentary of Washington in particular when Penton asked about him.

Create an account or sign in to comment